brian carroll on Sat, 28 Aug 1999 20:09:45 +0200 (CEST) |
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]
<nettime> ae fragments/virilio |
(the 9th of a 9 part series of architectural book reviews) ._______________________________________________________________. /_______________________________________________________________/ | working on 'the architecture of electricity' (ae) thesis to be | finished near 2000 Common Era. just finished writing this piece | today, which i propose is an archaeo-architectural (mis-) | reading of the architectural text by Paul Virilio, The | Lost Dimension. the upper-case letters on the website | will be of a smaller font size than the lowercase letters, and | these words will be hyperlinked to their definitions, as will | the numbered footnotes with the bibliographic information. of | the concepts in this piece, most all have been established in the | the thesis prior to this text (this is at the end of the thesis). | thus, a concept like the E-INFRASTRUCTURE has a whole section | detailing how electricity is produced and consumed, and that in | turn has another section about what ELECTRICITY is, etcetera. | feedback is welcome. bc |____________________________________________________________. a r c h i t e x t u r e z : an online community for hacking | and cracking the architectural code - www.architexturez.com | //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ______________________________________________________________________ P A U L V I R I L I O ______________________________________________________________________ An urban planner and architect, Paul Virilio published a dense philosophical text on ARCHITECTURE, L'espace critique in 1984. We examine the 1991 English translation The Lost Dimension here in relation to ELECTRICITY. Virilio opens with a comparison between the arc de triomphe and our present-day ELECTRONIC security systems of cameras, radars, and detectors at airports. (250) This juxtaposition between the gateways to the cities of the TRADITIONAL ORDER and ELECTRICAL ORDER is not coincidental. It is the result of a revolution in transportation brought on by ELECTRONIC telecommunications, wherein the "intramural-extramural opposition" of city boundaries collapses. (251) As Virilio states, our ARCHITECTURAL notion of SPACE-TIME, and thus REALITY, has been transformed within the ÆTHER: "...with the screen interface of computers, television and teleconferences, the surface of inscription, hitherto devoid of depth, becomes a kind of "distance," a depth of field of a new kind of representation, a visibility without any face-to-face encounter in which the vis-á-vis of the ancient streets disappears and is erased. In this situation, a difference of position blurs into fusion and confusion. Deprived of objective boundaries, the architectonic element begins to float in an electronic ether, devoid of spatial dimensions, but inscribed in the singular temporality of an instantaneous diffusion. From here on, people can't be separated by physical obstacles or by temporal distances. With the interfacing of computer terminals and video monitors, distinctions of here and there no longer mean anything." (252) That our "...constructed space occurs within an electronic topology..." is made evident by Virilio, who says that our new "telematic" gates, in terms of spatio-temporal access, replace the doorway: "The sound of gates gives way to the clatter of data banks and the rites of passage of a technical culture whose progress is disguised by the immateriality of its parts and networks... the [human]/machine interface replaces the facades of buildings as the surfaces of property allotments." (253) Likewise, our new ELECTRONIC SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, such as the COMPUTER, have become part of our urban plan for the BUILT ENVIRONMENT - SERVERs on the Internet COMPUTER NETWORK acting as buildings housing millions online within the dimensions of a few square feet - an ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE sustained in the ELECTRONIC TECHNOLOGY of MICROPROCESSORs, hardrives, MODEMs, TELEPHONE and POWER LINEs. (254n) Virilio declares this new ARCHITECTURAL ORDER is ELECTRICAL, an "electronic false-day" symbolized by the ELECTRICAL LIGHT, as opposed to sunlight or candlelight. (255) It is this new ELECTRICAL ENLIGHTENMENT which acts as the keys to the ELECTRONIC city, as Virilio states: "...the city from here on is deprived of gateway entries, it is because the urban wall has long been breached by an infinitude of openings and ruptured enclosures. While less apparent than those of antiquity, these are equally effective, constraining and segregating." (256) Thus, our ELECTRONIC MEDIA SYSTEMs of TELEPHONE, RADIO, TELEVISION, and COMPUTER are, in their own way, the city walls of the ELECTRICAL STATE. For example, a local TELEVISION newscast keeps certain people inside its broadcasted view of the city, while keeping others, outcasts, outside its ELECTRONIC REALITY. Virilio focuses upon the "cathode-ray window" of the TELEVISION and COMPUTER screen as an ELECTRONIC false-day "which brings to each viewer the light of another day and the presence of the antipodal place." (257) It is an example of the INTERFACE between two surfaces, between two ARCHITECTURAL ORDERs, one ELECTRICAL, the other not. This new ELECTRONIC INTERFACE is justified by speed of light SPACE-TIME, 186,000 miles/second, an absolute present in which there is no longer any distance, as Virilio writes: "...property boundaries, walls and fences no longer signify the permanent physical obstacle. Instead, they now form an interruption of an emission or of an electronic shadow zone which repeats the play of daylight and the shadow of buildings." (258) This VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION is the ARCHITECTURAL ORDER of ELECTRICITY - as, for example, the TELEVISION '"program guide" replaces the chain link fence' in outlining the community of a city in ELECTRONIC SPACE-TIME, as Virilio writes: "Where once the polis inaugurated a political theater, with its agora and its forum, now there is only a cathode-ray screen..." (259) "Where does the city without gates begin?" Virilio asks. It can be seen in the "invisible" monuments of the ELECTRICAL INFRASTRUCTURE: in "terminals, consoles, and electronic nightstands." The ARCHITECTURE then becomes "...an instrument of measure, a sum total of knowledge that, contending with the natural environment, becomes capable of organizing society's time and space." (260) Virilio then contrasts this "immateriality" of the ELECTRICAL ORDER of mass communications with the "materiality" of TRADITION. We propose that Virilio is describing our new ELECTRICAL ORDER, a unified ELECTRONIC SPACE-TIME and place, and inscribing an "introverted" ARCHITECTURE OF ELECTRICITY in relation to the non-ELECTRICAL ARCHITECTURE of the past. This is evidenced in the chapter "The Morphological Irruption", in which ELECTRONIC SPACE and TIME are equated by Virilio with instantaneous ELECTRONIC REALITY. (261) For Virilio, speed becomes a point of view, redefining CONSCIOUSNESS: "the depth of time of opto-electronic teleology displaces the old depth of field of topology." (262) As the author states, in this replacement of the depth of SPACE with the depth of TIME, "speed becomes the sole vector for electronic representation" in our ELECTRICAL TECHNOLOGIEs and in our BRAINs. (263) This aesthetic of disappearance "...no longer involves the visual horizon, nor the vanishing point of perspective..." as Virilio states, but instead, depth equals the absolute ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT of speed, relating the microcosmic measure of the ATOM with that of the macrocosmic universe: "The luminous point became the vanishing point of the speed of light, the non-place of its acceleration, a photon, electron acceleration that contributes to the present formation of the dimensions of infinite space, just as the point without dimension of ancient Greek geometry served to establish the dimensions of the finite world..." (264) Describing this new quantum REALITY of VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs, Virilio defines "telematics" of the form-image as "...not only the fact of binding informatics with instantaneous transmission across great distances. Telematics is first of all the instantaneity effect of the immediate broadcasting of a figure, its movement or its apparent extension through the interface of a screen." (265) The ELECTRON in turn becomes equivalent to a pixel in this new ELECTRICAL ORDER. The ELECTRONIC false-day thus arises with the ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT as measure, as Virilio states: "The final unit of measure, the final standard of transfer, is once more the absolute speed, the speed of light. We enter yet again into the latter-day solar cult, in which the rays of sunlight have become the standard of relativity and the standard transfer of all reality." (266) By this, Virilio concludes: "The light of speed illuminates the world and all its matter in the very instant in which it offers up its representation." (267) This metaphysical physicality between ELECTRONIC MATTER, ENERGY, and INFORMATION is, for Virilio, LIGHT speed becoming the absolute dimension and measure of SPACE-TIME. (268) We propose this concept unveils itself in an emergent ARCHITECTURE OF ELECTRICITY, wherein the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs of the ELECTRICAL ORDER, be they in the BRAIN or in the SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, are all interrelated via the drama of ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT speed. This leads Virilio to posit an "Improbable Architecture", a cinematic ARCHITECTURAL INTERFACE of telecommunications wherein "...the bourgeois home is merely the site of energy and other modes of supply. Its architecture is an intersection, a nodal point, a fixed pole on which inertia begins to renew the ancient sedentary ways of townspeople, legal citizens for whom the liberty to come and go is suddenly replaced by the liberation of home reception." (269) Likewise, within the new ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE, the home is a decentered node of our SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, such as TELEPHONE, RADIO, TELEVISION, and COMPUTER. Virilio then describes architectonic elements that INTERFACE with SPACE-TIME. For example, the genealogy of the ARCHITECTURAL window is traced from its origin as a doorway to the "third window" of the TELEVISION RECEIVER: "the television screen, a removable and portable window that opens onto the false day of the speed of light emissions. The television screen is an introverted window, one which no longer opens onto adjoining space but instead faces beyond the perceptible horizon... the specialized window... interrupts the passage of bodies. The specialized window is a puncture, a mediated opening for solar light and nearby perspectives. In this context the TV screen becomes a selector of electronic images, an audio-visual medium for the indirect light of the cathode tube." (270) In comparing the window of TRADITION with the TELEVISION RECEIVER as a window of the ELECTRICAL ORDER, Virilio thus juxtaposes the two ARCHITECTURAL ORDERs that define the ARCHITECTURE OF ELECTRICITY. This new "opto-electronic" real-estate also demarcates a 'stereophonic and stereoscopic doubling' of SPACE-TIME, constituting an ELECTRONIC "false day", as Virilio writes: "On the one hand there is the primary day, wherein we live; on the other is the secondary day, which is recorded somewhere for us." (271) For example, the digital ELECTRONIC false day can be paused, fast forwarded, erased, edited, and sampled in infinite ways, whereas the analog day is linear and one-way. Likewise, our understanding of the physicality of the ARCHITECTURAL building disintegrates in the ELECTRONIC interruption caused by our new "immaterial" SPACE-TIME MACHINEs. As Virilio states, our ARCHITECTURAL point-of-view is transformed from an optical perspective to an "opto-electronic pseudo-perspective, a (fantastic) accelerated perspective, one ruled less by the vanishing point than by the simultaneous vanishing of all points, and of all instants, in a transmission in which all points without any dimension (pixels) and all instants without perceptible duration compose an image whose formal perfection springs not from an optic convergence but from a commutation of various forms of information. In this world, the speed of electronic propagation is suddenly the equivalent of an ocular stability, which itself replaces, in the cathode interface, the ancient statics of materials." (272) The ARCHITECTURAL elements of door, window, and mirror are replaced by a cathode-ray framework and its ELECTRONIC false-day. This necessitates a crisis of physical dimension, described by Virilio in relation to Paxton's 1851 Crystal Palace: "...the advent of buildings stripped of any optic center, in which the structural architectonic of iron and glass behaves as the later image-form will behave in the computer terminals and the televised sequences. In the new trellis of lines, 625 or 819 lines, of imperceptible subtlety, the pixel replaces the bolt and rivet. The eye of the telespectator slides along the length of an infinite electronic perspective, and the architecture of light becomes nothing more than the computer's memory - a sequential, modular or matrix system that was prefigured by the first metallic structures..." (274) Likewise, our ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE is ARCHITECTURE anew, another ARCHITECTURAL ORDER in relation to TRADITION, ELECTRICAL. It changes our ARCHITECTURAL REALITY through architectonic SPACE-TIME MACHINEs. Juxtaposing a window with a TELEVISION screen thus 'bridges the gap' between the two ORDERs in an ARCHITECTURE OF ELECTRICITY. Virilio then asks: "...isn't it about time we began to wonder about the relationships between these new energy systems and those new modes of mass communications?" (276) We propose Virilio is referring to the ARCHITECTURAL import of the ELECTRICAL INFRASTRUCTURE of POWER, MEDIA, and TECHNOLOGY in relationship to humans, nature, and the BUILT ENVIRONMENT. This transparent ARCHITECTURAL ORDER of ELECTRICITY is revealed by Virilio when considering the metaphysics of INFORMATION, represented by ELECTRICAL ENERGY, fused with the physics of MATTER: "If informatics - with its networks, memory banks and terminals - is actually a kind of energetics, an energy form, then transmitted information becomes a mode of formation... the energy of information feeds inversely an alternative, extremely brief, discontinuous current of transformation, in which the rule of space and of the spatiality of extension of different rural and urban places gives way to temporality, and the nature of regimes of temporalities, produced by advanced technologies." (278) This paradoxical logic of equating ELECTRICAL INFORMATION with ELECTRICAL ENERGY in the formation of MATTER is similar to equating the ELECTRICAL ORDER with ARCHITECTURAL ORDER and the ELECTRICAL INFRASTRUCTURE with ARCHITECTURE. Virilio's equation for "realizing" ARCHITECTURE within, for example, TELEVISION RECEIVERs, TELEVISION STATIONs, and broadcasting ANTENNAE is not coincidental, it is intentional, but uncertainly so. For instance, Virilio alchemically writes that "...the habitual notions of height, length and width have undergone a transmutation, one that affects the organization of ocular and auditory perception, and thus the entire administration of territories and all construction. Now one architectonic element stands ready to supplant all others"- the ELECTRONIC window of the TELEVISION and COMPUTER screen. (280) For Virilio this transference is of utmost importance: "It reaches to the heart and soul, the principle and nature of architecture; it relegates the protocol of physical access - as well as the necessity of an effective presence - to a secondary plane of actual experience." (283) It transforms ELECTRONIC MATTER into ENERGY, and ENERGY into ELECTRONIC INFORMATION and vice versa, like lead into gold. This audiovisual tele-portation through these ELECTRONIC windows of tele-communications, what we posit here to be SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, is the affect of the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION upon the ARCHITECTURAL REALITY of SPACE-TIME, as Virilio states: "The cathode window and the matrix screen are able to displace doors and physical means of communication because cinematic representation has already displaced the reality of the effective presence, the real presence of people and things. Further, the accident of instantaneous transfer machinery displaces the substance of space-time, in favor of a kind of energy reduction and a hyper-cinematic reductionism that affects urbanism and architecture, but above all else re-orders geometry and the dimensions of physical space." (285) With the "nullity of all buildings", Virilio declares, "We have arrived... at the zero degree of architecture." (287) This SIGNALs the end of the TRADITIONAL ORDER of building with MATTER, and the emergence of a new LIGHT speed ELECTRICAL ORDER, constructing an "improbable" ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE by transmutation of ELECTRONIC ENERGY and INFORMATION. The Lost Dimension of SPACE then becomes its seizure in TIME, wherein Virilio states "...acceleration and deceleration, or the movement of movement, are the only true dimensions of space, of speed-space, of dromospheric space..." (289) This SPACE of speed is the absolute TIME of ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT - 186,000 miles/second, lightning fast. ELECTRICITY and the LIGHT speed of the ELECTRON thus becomes the ultimate referent. The ELECTRONIC false-day is founded within this new SPACE. Virilio states that "[i]t is first and foremost accidental and intensive... Its intensity is measured... by change of speed, a change that instantaneously produces a change of light and of representation." (291) This 'new day rising' of the universalizing ELECTRON is a different day from the TRADITIONAL ORDER based on relativity of the sun, as the author exposes: "[W]e have a subliminary and para-optic day that has no relationship whatsoever to direct observation, and in which representations and configurations arise less from the separation of the points, lines, and planes of visual experience, or image resolution, than from the interruption of projection sequences. The projection of the light of speed, which is paradoxical light, constructs the dimensions of our fields of action and of perception, fields in which the action is no longer separated from its representation, and so the gap between world time and human time ends. The relativist notions of length of speed and depth of time finally allow us to understand the paradox of non-separability of events." (293) This particular wave of thought leads to Virilio's 'chicken and egg' question: "Do we represent the construction, or construct the representation?" (295) More specifically, do we construct the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs of the ELECTRICAL ORDER within our BRAINs, or construct the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION within our SPACE-TIME MACHINEs? It seems, paradoxically, to be both at the same time. This 'point', as Virilio says, "...is that lost dimension that allows us to recuperate ourselves: that bug, that micro-processor of our mathematical and esthetic representation and our temporal and spatial configurations." (297) Thus, the speed of ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT 'bridges the gap' between the NATURAL WORLD of our BRAINs and the VIRTUAL WORLDs of our COMPUTER MICROPROCESSORs. Virilio goes even further into the meta-physical connection between ELECTRONIC MATTER, ENERGY and INFORMATION of the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION constituting ARCHITECTURAL REALITY: "Finally, informatics now appears, as a kind of energetics, as a mode of formation, because the punctum of electronic action is virtually or practically instantaneous... the point, the pixel, is the imminence of physical dimensions, the accident of the transfer of the traced, as of all surface or volume projectivity. Thus, if the "[human]-machine" interface is the product of electronic interactivity combined with relativist non-separability, then the synthetic image is the visible consequence of a static conception of real time and real space. This purely theoretical and quantitative conception finds its apparent, practical confirmation in the appearance and disappearance of those form-images composed of points without dimension and instants without duration, digitally controlled by the algorithms of an encoded language." (299) The question of INTERFACE between these VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs of our BRAINs and SPACE-TIME MACHINEs then arises, with Virilio declaring: "Ours is a crisis of cutting and joining, a crisis of editing; we have passed beyond the crisis of montage." (302) This detailed ARCHITECTURAL connection becomes "...a crisis of representation rather than construction..." (304) We interpret this to say that the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION in the BRAIN of HOMO ELECTRUS takes precedence over the experience of our SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, like the TELEVISION and COMPUTER screen, and their ELECTRONIC false-day. The critical question for Virilio becomes: "In which light do mental images appear? What day do they inhabit?" (306) We propose that, as a CHARGED PARTICLE in an ELECTROMAGNETIC WAVE, be it a PHOTON or an ELECTRON, it is the same LIGHT of speed, whether in BRAIN or SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, and in this way, the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION is one and the same, only housed in different "containers" or mediums of transference. Thus, our ARCHITECTURAL CONSCIOUSNESS is unified under the onus of an absolute ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT speed, whether of the NATURAL, ARTIFICIAL, or VIRTUAL WORLD - fusing and confusing REALITY with the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATION in the form-image whereby ELECTRONIC MATTER equals ENERGY equals INFORMATION. (308) Virilio concurs by stating that it is the ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT, no longer sublimated, which "...is now recognized as that which gives form to images - to images of consciousness, such as mental and ocular images, and to our consciousness of optic or opto-electronic images." (310) This speed of LIGHT now literally becomes the shortest route between two points. (312) Certainly, the shortest route between the two spatio-temporal ARCHITECTURAL ORDERs, TRADITIONAL and ELECTRICAL, is this very same ELECTROMAGNETIC LIGHT of speed. Paradoxically, one is a relativistic sunlit day and the other is its antipode, a universalizing ELECTRONIC false-day illuminating the night- The two ARCHITECTUREs combining in an ARCHITECTURE OF ELECTRICITY. Virilio refers to a secondary, improbable ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE when writing of "the mutual development of the electronic urban environment and the architecture of systems... whose efficiency none can deny." (314) It is in this nodal infra-structure, an ARCHITECTURAL interface with the ELECTRONIC city by which a "critical" and thus political SPACE emerges. As Virilio writes: "Since what is interactive is also interchangeable, the urban has lost its form, with the sole exception of the form-image without dimension, the point or punctum which is everywhere while the measurable length is nowhere." (316) VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs of the ELECTRONIC form-image are transmutated between MATTER, ENERGY, and INFORMATION in our SPACE-TIME MACHINEs and our BRAINs. In so doing, they form an improbable ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE, which Virilio believes poses an ever-present danger: "...totalitarian unity proceeds disguised by the advances of civil and military technologies, advances that have no interest whatsoever in democracy." (318) This critical SPACE, or critical STATE "becomes critical by virtue of the instantaneity of means of mass communication as much as through the performances of delivery vectors of massive destruction." (320) It is this critical STATE of "pure war" that is inherent in the interaction of ELECTRICAL POWER, MEDIA, and TECHNOLOGY, fusing offense and defense in an uncertain certainty of communicating destruction. (322) For instance, NUCLEAR POWER has a paradoxical dual-use: as a POWERPLANT sustaining CYBERSPACE and in an ATOMIC BOMB destroying CYBERSPACE. Virilio focusses upon the critical SPACE, or instantaneous TIME, of VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs which recreate REALITY inside of our ELECTRONIC SPACE-TIME MACHINEs: wherein every place is the front line, every time is war, and everyone is a soldier: "Everything is overexposed in the interface of an interactivity that strips reality of the possibility of places, things, or adversaries meeting face to face." (324) For example, ongoing wargames in CYBERSPACE can quickly turn into a VIRTUAL warfare of ideas and ideologies, as Virilio suggests: "We now have a topology of the non-place as a consequence of the non-sense of nuclear strategy, an "electronic" as much as an "atomic" war-game, in which the instantaneous interface replaces the face-to-face encounters of armies." (326) The origin of the Internet COMPUTER NETWORK is one instance of the existential BEING in a STATE of perpetual war. The ELECTRONIC false-day then becomes an strategic exercise in speed of LIGHT warfare wherein, as Virilio writes, "[t]he speed of violence becomes the violence of an unsurpassed speed, and the speed of light becomes the standard measure for war, for its context, its essence and nature." (328) In concluding, Virilio declares that we are in a STATE of pure war. We propose this warfare is BEING waged between the VIRTUAL REPRESENTATIONs of our CONSCIOUSNESS, be they in the BRAIN of HOMO ELECTRUS or in our ELECTRONIC SPACE-TIME MACHINEs, battling for our individual and collective REALITY at 186,000 miles/second. In so doing, a meta-physical ELECTROMAGNETIC ARCHITECTURE emerges in the ÆTHER via the formation of an alchemical transmutation of ENERGY into INFORMATION, of sunlight into ELECTRIC LIGHT, 'bridging the gap' between the two ARCHITECTURAL ORDERs in an ARCHITECTURE OF ELECTRICITY. ______________________________________________________________________ Lost Dimension. Paul Virilio. Translated by Daniel Moshenberg. Semiotext(e), c.1991. NY, NY. (250) p.11 (251) p.12 (252) p.13 (253) pp.13-14 (255) p.14 (256) p.15 (257) p.17 (258) p.18 (259) pp.18-19 (260) p.22 (260.5) p.22 (261) p.30 (262) p.31 (263) pp.34-35 (264) p.43 (265) p.51 (266) p.59 (267) p.59 (268) pp.62-63 (269) pp.72-73 (270) pp.78-79 (271) p.81 (272) pp.85-86 (274) pp.93-94 (276) p.95 (278) p.95 (280) pp.98-99 (283) pp.98-99 (285) p.99 (287) p.100 (289) p.102 (291) p.102 (293) pp.102-103 (295) p.103 (297) p.104 (302) p.112 (304) p.112 (306) p.115 (308) pp.116-117 (310) p.117 (312) p.117 (314) p.119 (316) pp.120-122 (318) p.127 (320) p.130 (322) pp.130-132 (324) pp.132-138 (326) p.138 (328) p.138 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ (254n) This is evidenced in popular advertising imagery, such as Cobalt Networks and Compaq computer server advertisements showing servers as buildings representing electronic skyscrapers in the new electronic cityscape. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ # distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission # <nettime> is a moderated mailing list for net criticism, # collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets # more info: majordomo@bbs.thing.net and "info nettime-l" in the msg body # archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime@bbs.thing.net